The Mountain Meadows Massacre

The Mountain Meadows Massacre   Introduction: JOURNEY TO CALIFORNIA On May 1, 1857, a train of over forty wagons, several carriages, 1000 head of cattle, hundreds of horses, and about 142 pioneer men, women and children left Arkansas for California. Tension was building at this time among the Mormon people, who were becoming fearful of the federal government. President James Buchanan had received distorted reports of the terrible activities in Utah. He sent a new governor to Utah to replace the Mormon governor in office, Brigham Young. The Mormons feared their own destruction by the federal government. The various Mormon Militia units were instructed to be ready to march on a moment's notice to any part of the territory. Because the settlers in Utah had not been friendly, the pioneers were alert. However, they were expecting no trouble from the Indians. On Tuesday morning, September 8, 1857 the Indians attacked the emigrants, killing seven men and wounding sixteen others before they were turned back. The pioneers withstood the attacking Indians for four days, leaving the pioneers with no water and their ammunition nearly gone. THE MASSACRE The entire truth will probably never be known because most of the documents and diaries of the participants were destroyed. The surviving children were able to supply details on the massacre itself, however. Bishop John D. Lee approached the train under a flag of truce and convinced the pioneers that he had persuaded the Indians to let them go if they would leave their wagons and possessions to the Indians. After deliberating, the suffering group could find no other way out and they agreed. The pioneers were told that it should appear to the Indians that they were the Mormon's prisoners. Lee sent in a wagon and the emigrants' weapons were loaded in to it. The wounded were then loaded into two wagons and two other wagons were loaded with the youngest of the children. These wagons left first followed by the women and older children on foot. The men were lined up single file, and parallel to a single file of Mormon Militiamen and this group followed about a quarter of a mile behind. As the group moved out, the waiting Indians moved in and began to loot the goods the pioneers had left behind. A short distance later, Lee rose up in his stirrups and shouted "Do your duty!" and each Mormon shot the member of the train standing next to him. At about the same time up ahead, Mormon Militia disguised as Indians, and the real Indians, moved in on the women and older children, shooting, clubbing and axing them to death. CONCLUSIONS AND CONSEQUENCES No effort was made to give the bodies a decent burial. Foraging animals scattered the bones over a great distance. In 1859, a passing detachment of the 2nd Dragoons, Commanded by Captain Rubin P. Campbell,  stopped and gathered what bones they could find into one grave. A rock cairn was erected with a carved stone and the words "Here lie the bones of one hundred and twenty men, women and children from Arkansas, murdered on the 10th day of September, 1857." Captain Campbell painted a cross-line beam above the cairn with the words "Vengeance is mine, saith the Lord. I will repay." The two wagonloads of children who had not been killed were adopted into Mormon homes. It is believed that 18 of the children survived. In 1859, Captain James Lynch of the U.S. Army took possession of these young survivors and returned them to relatives in Arkansas. Although there were many investigations, no punishment was handed out for the crime until 20 years later. Lee wrote out a full confession and was found guilty and sentenced to death by firing squad. The Following is fron the 2nd US Cavalry Archives: MASSACRE AT MOUNTAIN MEADOWS Leaving Camp Floyd, Utah, April 21, 1859, Company E, under Captain Campbell, now returned from sick leave, was ordered to march to Santa Clara as a protection to travelers to California and to investigate Indian depredations in that vicinity. Upon their arrival at Mountain Meadows, 150 miles south of camp Floyd, they suddenly rode in sight of many skeletons of human beings scattered about on the prairie. Assistant Surgeon Brewer gives us in his report a detailed account of his findings on this day from a doctor’s standpoint, and Captain Campbell reports the number found to be about 150. These people had been emigrants from Arkansas on their way to California the previous year. They were here attacked by the Mormons with their faces painted as Indians and led by John D. Lee, then a high dignitary of the Mormon church. After four days of fighting, Lee took the paint from his face, and going to the immigrants, told them he would give them protection from the Indians back to Cedar City if they would lay down their arms. After surrendering all weapons, men, women, and children were massacred, except for a few children too young to give an account of the occurrence. These were later found living among the Mormon families at Cedar City. After interring the remains of these unfortunate people, Company E proceeded on its mission.