Pyrenees crossing - snow and cognac
Remembered in March 2007, by R. W. Rynerson
The return of gray weather here in Denver reminded me of the bad cold
that I picked up in Hamburg in March 2005, but then some questions from
a colleague reminded me of another trip, in March 1971, on which the
sun shone, a cold was cleared up, the Mediterranean was deep blue, and
a few dollars went a long way. In fact, I realized later that it
was part of my best 24 hours on my own outside of Berlin.
Unfortunately, my handy Voightlander folding 35mm camera went out of
order, and I bought a Spanish Kodak Instamatic for this part of the
journey. The pictures that you are about to see are scratchy, the
color is starting to vanish... but then so is the way of life that I
briefly experienced. The day began as an interesting bit of
itinerary and ended with a profound experience. Every Berlin
veteran must have a leave story to tell; the O. Henry ending of mine
caught me off guard.
WAY BACK WHEN… March 1971
After circling through some of Mediterranean Spain, I
found myself in the old station in Zaragoza. (It is shown in the
current issue of Passenger Train Journal
next to the recently opened huge replacement station.) I had
arrived there the day before on one of the tilting, streamlined Talgo
trains, not knowing that I could have waited thirty years more and then
traveled on that type of train between Portland and Seattle.
There were other things to see, though.

Spain had just discontinued 3rd Class (!) rail travel, and I was catching the morning local train up into the Pyrenees, to the French border, a train which still carried a 3rd Class wooden coach on the tail end.
It turned out that they way they discontinued 3rd Class was to repaint
the signs on the best of the 3rd Class cars, so that they were now 2nd
Class (at the higher fare). In the interest of my education,
however, I joined some local people on the wooden benches in this car,
and bumped along with them for about an hour till the conductor came
and told me that this car would be taken off the train at Huesca, the
last real city on the trip.
When I moved forward into 2nd Class, I felt satisfied at the thought
that my brief experience with 3rd Class might be the most interesting
part of the ride, but it became more interesting as the train
climbed. Somehow, I had the idea that the Pyrenees were not that
big a deal. As the track began to twist and turn, I started to
change my mind. And then, tantalizing at first, some of the turns
revealed a massive front of mountains ahead. Snow was blowing in
clouds off of them. In the foreground, the train continued making
stops at tinier and tinier villages.
In these villages -- it was Sunday morning -- life barely seemed to
exist. Photo 3 shows one of the first glimpses of the
snow-covered mountains. Photo 4 shows an 18-year old (approx)
woman who alighted from the train in this tiny village. She was
dressed as plainly as the much older women in my 2nd Class compartment
who told me that I should save my film for the really beautiful part of
the trip ahead.
In remembering how this landscape intrigued me at the time, I realize
now that growing up in the Pacific Northwest and living in Germany in
the Army, I really did not know much about deserts or drylands. I
saw that as the train climbed, we were following a series of dams and
lakes that stored up snow melt run-off for use in irrigating the
otherwise bleak farmlands of northern Spain.
I also remember how interesting it was to see so little
population. Americans have the idea of Europe as being densely
settled, but the villages here were tiny, as shown in my previous
slides, and there were few of them.
Of course, this trip was only made three decades after the Spanish
Civil War, and I could not tell how much poverty and underdevelopment
was a legacy of long ago, or a consequence of the drylands, or how much
was the result of that bitter struggle.
Continuing into the Pyrenees... to freedom
One of the things that I noticed about this train heading up
into the mountains is how many young people were taking it for access
to day hikes. Sometimes it was just two or three students, as in
the attached slide, and sometimes it was a larger group of young men
and women.
Only the night before, I had experienced some of the many reminders of
the tight social control in the arch-conservative Spain of
Generalissimo Francisco Franco. Earlier in the trip, I had run
into more police inspections, border guard attention, and hints of
secret police activity than in any of the other countries west of the
Iron Curtain that I had visited.
The Spanish Civil War had ended 32 years before my March 1971 visit,
but during its first three decades, the Fascist government of Spain was
able to control its security through the kind of informal means that I
had witnessed in several situations. For example:
Following traditional practice, a night watchman patrolled each street
in urban areas. He had a big key ring with keys to the street
gates of each house, hostal
(Spanish for a pension or bed & breakfast), etc. On the night
before this train trip, when I arrived back at my hostal after seeing a
film, I had to clap my hands loudly. The watchman appeared out of
the shadows and let me in to my hostal. He had to receive a tip.
The watchman traditionally was a retired military person or civil
servant. This provided him with a supplement to his government
pension, but it also meant that someone who was dependent on the
government knew everything that was going on in that street, including
who came and went at each home.
As urban life became more complex, an informal call by police on the watchman was no longer enough. In 1968, the Organizacion Contrasubversiva Nacional was formed to give the Fascist government a real secret police department.
How did this relate to the students' desire for fresh air?
Outdoor sports and hiking were among the few socially acceptable
outlets in which they could get away from the tight social controls and
the political controls. No wonder these passengers looked so
happy!
Passenger count gets thinner.. as does the air
The passenger count on the local train to the French border
continued to thin out, while the scenery became more and more
dramatic. An elderly Spanish lady was amused at my picture-taking
and told me to wait until we reached the higher elevations.
Fortunately, I took her advice, because things were about to unfold in
a different way than I had expected.
The train schedules in the Deutsche Bundesbahn's Ausland Kursbuch
(Foreign Timetables) France and Spain sections disagreed with each
other slightly, but that was not unusual. The Spanish tables
showed one set of times and the French tables showed a slightly
different set of times. The train was running on a third set of
times, but every source was within a few minutes of the other.
(This is not uncommon when paper timetables have to be circulated
between companies.)
As the train eased into the Spanish border station of Canfranc, I was
prepared for the usual mad scramble to go through Customs while
changing from the Broad Gauge Spanish train to the Standard Gauge
French train. Instead, the few remaining passengers wandered
off. No one headed into Customs.
I stopped for a moment to look around, and saw that the railway crew
was getting ready to couple a standby car onto the equipment of my
train to be ready for the Sunday afternoon return crowd from the
mountains. I snapped photo 11, as I looked at a scene that I
would have thought was in old Colorado. The spare car had a
wooden body and the mountains behind closed in on the little town.
Cautiously, I approached a Spanish officer in the tri-cornered hat of
the Guardia Civil. Where should I go for the train to
France? After he understood what I was asking, he laughed.
He made some comment, but I couldn't understand it. I asked if it
was okay to walk into the Customs area, and he waved his arm to
indicate that I was welcome. Cautiously, I walked into the room
where baggage would have been opened. There was no one
there. I walked a bit further and realized that I was headed out
the French side. No one was there.
Stepping out onto the platform, I realized what the guard must have
been trying to tell me. Photo 12 shows what I saw. The
tracks were completely covered by snow. In some places, there
were icicles hanging on the electric catenary. It was obvious
that there would be no train coming. Was I at a dead-end?
I stumbled through the snow to a hut from which I could see smoke
rising. A lone SNCF (French) railwayman was going through the
motions of tending the empty yard. As best as he could, he tried
to explain to me that the line was closed by a storm or a washout, but
that a bus would be running. I walked back through the snow,
still half expecting to be yelled at by a policeman or a border guard,
but nothing happened.
Back in the station, I looked around until I found the waiting room and
an SNCF ticket counter. Posted there was an emergency timetable,
showing a bus connection between Canfranc, Spain and Bedous,
France. Bedous was so small that it did not even show on my
German timetable. Instead of a mad dash to catch the French Marchandise et voyageurs (Mixed freight and passenger train) I was going to have over two hours in Canfranc.
I thought of buying more film, as I only had a few frames left.
But it was Sunday, and in conservative Spain almost everything was
closed. The one store that sold film, I was told, was among the
places closed.
So, I headed into the station restaurant to get some lunch and pass the
time. And that was the beginning of getting to know a bit more
about the people of the Pyrenees.
Dining and then a stroll in the Pyrenees...
The railroad station restaurant was huge, with tables set
with white tablecloths for perhaps over 100 customers. There were
three or four customers in the place. A television was running in
one corner with live, beginning to end coverage of a Catholic religious
procession. The hostess seated me at a table with an older man
who was dressed like a Basque. By now, I had been in Europe for
almost two years, so I was not surprised at being seated with other
people, but what followed was not typical.
I didn't order wine with my meal, but my tablemate simply ordered
another glass for and poured some of the wine from his bottle for
me. We broke bread together with me saying my few words of thanks
in broken Spanish. Otherwise, we said little, but it broke the
ice. It turned out that he would be on my bus.
When it came time to load the bus, I found that it was the 11-passenger
Citreon all-purpose vehicle one saw everywhere in France then.
These were used as police vans, as station shuttles, as delivery
trucks, anything that one might imagine cutting into their sheet metal
bodies. Photo 10 was snapped by the bus driver, and I look a
little goofy in it, but you need to have an idea of how we were going
to assault the summit of the mountain pass.
The Garage del Val d'Aspe bus
had been chartered by the SNCF for us. The company name, a
mixture of Spanish and French, was typical of the language spoken
there. The driver had brought a buddy along, which turned out
later to be a good thing. As we pulled out, though, I was
concerned to see how both of them smoked and waved their hands while
driving the two-lane mountain highway. Later on, I learned that
this was the highway that Hannibal had taken with his elephants on his
epic march to attack Rome. I wondered if his drivers paid better
attention to the road.
Just before departure, a well-dressed Spanish man arrived and said
kissy farewells to a VERY well-dressed French woman, presenting her
with a bottle of Spanish Cognac. We others gawked: a teen-aged
girl, an elderly lady, two downscale Spanish guys, and my "Basque"
tablemate, none of us so glamorous. I looked around at our bunch
of passengers and realized that we were from the cast for a disaster
movie.
In a few minutes, we were passing into deep snow, and in what
seemed like about half an hour of driving, we were stuck in the snow,
on the cliff side of the icy highway. When we got out to survey
the situation, we found that if the driver tried to rock the bus back
and forth out of the snow, our bus might go over the edge.
This being conservative Spain, it was decreed that the men would get
out and push the bus, while the women remained inside it. I felt
safer outside. We made little progress, and it was decided to
chain up the bus. Now I understood why the driver's buddy had
come along. I also learned what the large plastic sheet in the
back of the bus was for. The driver and his buddy took turns on
the ground on the plastic sheet messing with the chains.
I was designated to be the flagman for this project, since my Spanish/French was of little help. I would shout Attencion
in a combination of languages when the occasional other vehicle came
by, so the man chaining up could get his legs out of the roadway.
With the chains on the bus, we male passengers and the driver's friend
all pushed, and the bus rolled free of the snowbank and ran ahead to a
flatter spot. I found myself walking briskly along in the snow in
street shoes and in the raincoat I had brought for Spring
weather. I noticed that I was getting ahead of the older men, who
took it easy, and then I noticed that the altitude was getting to
me. I had expected to go through this part of the trip in a train
passing through a tunnel, not go mountaineering.
The attached photo 13 shows us catching up with the bus. You can
see a snow pole on the left side of the road to show where the edge
was. The man with the hood pulled up on his jacket is my "Basque"
friend. By now, we were all old friends, and back on the bus, I
pulled out some hard candies that I had carried along. Everyone
was glad to have one, but then I had to laugh: the elderly woman
said, "of course... American soldiers always give out candy!" I
had perpetuated a stereotype.
A few minutes later we passed what the Spanish considered to be
snow-fighting equipment -- a flatbed truck with a blade plow on the
front. Then we entered a ski area, enlightening to me, as I never
knew that Spain had skiing. We lost more time trapped in crazy
traffic jams in the resort.
At one point we watched a couple of men build a snow pyramid to hold a
35 mm camera. Then a whole group of skiers formed up, their
photographer started the self-timer, and ran to get into the group
shot. At that point, traffic started to move and our little bus
pulled between the camera and the group. The shutter clicked and
they got a close-up of the side of our bus. I was glad that my
Spanish was so limited, as I don't think that the things that the group
of skiers was shouting at our driver were very nice.
The bus climbed further, and soon we were rounding a curve that
revealed a massive fortress blasted into the rock facing France.
With my Army experience in Berlin, I found myself counting trucks and
equipment. Was France going to invade Spain? They last time
they had done that was under Napoleon, as best as I could recall, but I
guessed the Spanish were not taking chances.
I assumed that the border was coming up, after all our hairpin turns,
and there it was. One last reminder of Franco's Spain was coming
up.
Last stop in Spain...
Here
are the last hours of March 28, 1971, the end of my week in
Spain. No, I don't always remember exact dates from that long
ago, but I found the attached movie ticket with some other items from
the trip. The evening before my bus ride over the Pyrenees, I had
watched "Paint Your Wagon" in Spanish, with Lee Marvin. The part
of the mayor in an old Western town was played by Tom McCall, who was
actually the Governor of Oregon at that time. The Spanish crowd
cheered and shouted "Toro, Toro!" for the scene in which a bull
rampaged through the movie town.
All of that, in dry Zaragoza, seemed far away that next afternoon in
the midst of the snow and ice at the border crossing. The Spanish
customs post did look like it belonged in a movie, however. It
was perched on the edge of a cliff into which the two-lane roadway was
cut. There was little room for any traffic or inspections, other
than in the road. A red-and-white customs barrier blocked the
road as the border guards waved us to a stop.
On
the attached 1938 map, the rail line is shown as a black line crossing
the border west of Mt. Perdido (10,994 ft). From breakfast time,
I had started on this map in Zaragoza, passed through Huesca, and in
mid-afternoon was at the crossing.
The guards and the driver/s had a long discussion about the events of
the day and then we presented our papers. On previous European
border crossings, I had tried only presenting the relevant documents,
and then they would ask for more. This time I pulled out
everything, and it made quite a pile of paper:
+ Portugese language orders
+ Spanish language orders
+ French language orders
+ Berlin travel documents, in Russian, English and French
+ Army DA31 Leave and Pass Form
+ My Army identity card
You can read more in my webpages on the paperwork that we soldiers generated at: Berlin 1969: Documents/Papiere .
The border guards pounced on the Russian language document. My
travel orders had been stamped by the Soviet Army when I left Berlin
via Marienborn. I was a bit nervous, because the losing side in
the Spanish Civil War had been involved with Soviet (Stalinist)
"advisors" and "volunteers" and these guards worked for the winning
side (that had been involved with their German Nazi and Italian Fascist
equivalents). They studied the document carefully and then I saw
them flip it over and on the back was printed a purple reproduction of
our Berlin Commanding General's signature and rubber stamp.
I think that they were reading the French text with the
signature. Everyone else on the bus was getting waved through, so
they could watch with me as the guards' lips moved as they read the
Berlin travel authorization. The guards were now impressed, and
in turn, everyone on the bus was highly impressed. One of the
border officers returned my paperwork with a smart flourish and a
salute. One of them also explained that it was a pleasure to pass
through the "first American of Spring." I breathed a sigh of relief.
The red-and-white barrier was raised and we were rolling
downhill. Around a curve, we saw a French fort cut into the rock
walls of the next cliff, facing Spain. They were ready with a
mirror-image of the fort I had just seen on the south side of the pass
in case the Spanish invaded them.
I kept wondering where the French border post would be. In the
meantime, we suddenly began making good time. Unlike the lone
Spanish blade plow, the French were using an elaborate snow and ice
clearing vehicle that scraped the road bare. Our driver continued
his conversation with his buddy, waving his cigarette with one hand,
while steering down the mountain pass with the other. I tried not
to think of those little news stories in the back of the papers,
headlined "Bus Plunges Off Cliff."
The French border post finally appeared in a pleasant mountain valley
setting, far inside their country. Our driver used their phone to
call the railway dispatcher and then reassured us that they would hold
our train. I couldn't believe that, but hoped he was right.
There was no excitement about my paperwork here-- the French barely
paid any attention to it and waved us all through.
Further down the valley, one question was answered as I looked down and
saw what looked like a washed out bridge on the railway. This
apparently was where it was shut down.
Picturesque village... and a realization
And then we were in tiny Bedous, not shown on many maps, and there was the SNCF station, with snow-free rails, and-- our train was gone.
The teenage girl of our bus group left to visit her friend in town--
this was the end of the line for her. For the rest of us, it was
cold, and an icy stream bubbled nearby. Picturesque, but we were
getting tired of picturesque.
Instead of being a disaster, this turned into one more surprise. The Chef de Gare
(Stationmaster) took pity on us and invited us to join him in his
heated office (the waiting room was unheated). He was a jovial
host and we all conversed in the local mixture of Spanish and French,
with me being able to make out that the stationmaster had held the same
rank in the French Army that I had in the U.S. Army. This
immediately made us comrades in arms, although of different
generations. Someone suggested that we should toast that, if we
had something to drink.
At
that point, the well-dressed woman who had attracted everyone's
attention in Canfranc reminded us that she had the bottle of Spanish
Cognac that she had been given. She went to her bag to pull it
out, and while she did that, to my American amazement, the
stationmaster pulled out enough shot glasses from his desk drawer for
all of us. Americans would not be surprised to find extra coffee
cups in a stationmaster's desk, but shot glasses caught me off
guard. The last photo in this series shows us celebrating our
adventures of the day, the French and U.S. Armies, the SNCF (even the
dispatcher who had decided to send the train out without us), and
whatever other excuse we had for finishing off the bottle.
The Cognac was powerful. I went outside into the cold for a while
and walked along the banks of the creek to stop my head from
spinning. That photo was the last frame on my Instamatic film and
it was getting dark. I supposed that we would sit around in the
station till the last train of the evening departed.
Instead, this day would not quit surprising me. The Spanish guy
on the right in the group photo had been trying to get the attention of
Our Lady of the Cognac. He suggested that they go into town and
get a bite of supper. She responded by agreeing, but added that
they should take "the American soldier" with them. Another one of
the Spanish men volunteered to join us. And so, as the sunlight
turned off behind the mountains, we walked down to the little village
center with its crooked streets that looked like a Hollywood film set
and found an inn that was serving dinner.
It was a simple, but good meal, but what I recall best, besides being
amused at being the chaperone for this meal, was the television news.
On French television, I found myself watching film of a column of GI's
passing through a swamp in South Vietnam, water up to their necks,
holding their rifles over their heads. My new companions carried
on their conversation, but I sat there with my head spinning. It
was no longer the Cognac, but rather the weight of the realization that
I was not only not going to Vietnam -- something that everyone assumed
when I went into the service in 1968 -- but that I had learned so many
things and was only five to six months away from finally getting out of
the Army.
(I had left home after my leave in January 1969 and was not to return
home again until September 1971. I had used all of my leave for
travel in Europe, sure that I would soon be ordered to Vietnam, with a
leave at home on my way from Berlin to Southeast Asia. Those
anticipated orders never came.)
We finished our meal and met the others back at the train
station. The train was an "emu" (electric multiple unit) set that
had open seating, very much like a North American commuter train.
We sat together and continued our conversation, while other passengers
gawked openly at us, trying to figure out who we were.
The Chef de Gare stood on the platform and blew his whistle to signal
the engineer to proceed, and then as our windows rolled past him and we
waved, he saluted us, military-style. There was an elderly lady
watching us whose mouth dropped open when she saw that.
In busy Pau where the Bas-Pyrenees rail main line cuts across from the
Mediterranean to the Atlantic, our group split up. Some were
destined there, some were transferring east toward Lourdes, and some--
as I -- were transferring west toward Bordeaux and on to Paris.
The Cognac lady smiled at us and headed for a comfortable sleeping
car. The two Spanish guys who had been trying to get her
attention headed somewhere back in the long string of 2nd Class
cars. I found a 2nd Class car marked for Paris-Austerlitz and
wedged myself in the corner of a compartment so I would be able to
sleep. For a time, I was alone in the compartment, reflecting on
the experiences of this amazing day and on the changes that I had
experienced in myself during my two years in Europe. Then a group
of French sailors stormed into the compartment at Bordeaux. Sea
air blew into the open window as we rolled out toward the Loire and
Paris and I thought of home and the Oregon Coast. The crowded Pyrenees Express seemed to be part of a different world as it hustled us into that night.
--rwr--
Postscript:
While my story above describes what I thought at the time, much more
was happening. In the following excellent website, the story of
organized neglect for the French (SNCF) part of this rail line is
described. The French portion of the line has been temporarily shut
down since the year before my visit till the time of this writing in
2007. As we learn, there is no money for this low productivity
line. The website is in French, but for readers unfamiliar with
that language it is a beautifully realized site and will benefit those
who take a few minutes to check the illustrations.
Nicholas Quierzy's site tells the complete story of the line.
The old road that we traveled in March 1971 has been superseded, first
by a bypass of the ski area, and then by a new, high-speed highway and
tunnel. A colleague of mine, wise in the ways of the highway
lobby, immediately guessed that the new highway was supposed to bring
"economic development" -- Europeans being no smarter than North
Americans when highway money is waved in front of them. So, in a
place where there is allegedly no money for restoring the out-of-action
rail line, there is massive funding available for a road that has
contributed to the dramatic growth of long-haul truck traffic between
the Iberian Peninsula and France. The following English language
link discusses this issue.
Pyrenees Freight Transport.
Wikipedia in French, with a view of the vandalized ruins of the great station at Canfranc: Wikipedia French .
And a blunter description of the spectacular ghost line in either language -- English readers will recognize the French word prétexte
in their discussion of the use of a March 1970 wreck as the reason for
"temporarily" shutting down the line, or read it in English as pretext. Recent information from visitors to Canfranc posted in either French or English.
Exploration urbaine: forbidden places. (French)
Urban exploration: forbidden places. (English)
Return to Stories/Geschichte table of contents.
