1987: Bob called Lyla and asked her to check hospital records as to whether an ob'gyn patient named Fullerton was admitted to Memorial in December 1965, and if so, what doctor signed the birth certificate for the daughter who was born to her. Rick and John beat Lyla to the hospital records room, and Rick stole Sabrina's file, but Lyla managed to locate proof of Mrs. Fullerton's admission on December 10, 1965.
Lyla Montgomery and young Casey Peretti were having their struggles with romance as well. After John's tirade over their age difference, Lyla became concerned about how people would view her romance with Casey, and when Casey offered to move out, she agreed. Lyla couldn't tolerate the separation, so she decided to defy public opinion and asked him to return. Their bliss was challenged by Casey's old flame, Taylor Baldwin, who joined the Memorial staff. Taylor's arrival stirred Lyla's insecurities, and Casey feared that if Taylor learned about his romance with Lyla, she'd try to come between them. Once again, Lyla had to keep her romance under wraps. Taylor managed to find out about it anyway and was undeterred in her quest--Taylor always got what she wanted. Casey confronted her about the way she'd been ingratiating herself into his life. The showdown led to a kiss, and Taylor took great pleasure in telling Lyla about Casey's passionate slip. Lyla told Casey it was either she or Taylor. Knowing that he'd been crazy to lose her, Casey took Lyla into the hospital linen closet and proposed. Because of their age difference, and because she was not interested in having more children, Lyla was hesitant. Casey responded by telling her over and over how much he wanted to marry her, buy Lyla was still uncertain. Casey was relentless, and Lyla was just about to give in when she learned that he's proposed to Taylor when they were involved. Although she was very torn, Lyla told him no. Casey moved our of the bedroom, then out of the house.
During one of Lyla's singing performances at the Mona Lisa, Case brought her a single rose, and Lyla was touched. Heather's former manager, Otis, was at the Mona Lisa and he offered Lyla a new gig in New York and a possible recording contract. Although Margo and Casey thought Lyla was running away from a marriage she truly wanted, Lyla accepted Otis's offer. Hurt and alone, Casey made Taylor dinner one night, had too much to drink and dozed off. When Casey woke up and realized how much he had drunk and who he was with, he freaked out. Realizing what he'd almost lost, Casey, along with Tom and Margo flew to New York to be at Lyla's opening. Lyla was thrilled to see Casey and sang her newest song, "From Now On," to him. After Lyla's singing engagement, she and Casey toured New York, and she realized she couldn't live without him. To Casey's great delight, Lyla accepted his umpteenth marriage proposal.
Lyla and Casey asked Tom and Margo to be matron of honor and best man at their wedding. Lyla and Casey Peretti were married in the hospital chapel with the whole Peretti family from Boston in attendance.