Tuesday, December 7, 2004      Twin Falls, Idaho

 

LOCAL/STATE NEWS

 

Plane crash kills two

The Times-News and

The Associated Press

 

BELLEVUE -- A charter airplane crashed near Bellevue Monday, killing two people.

 

The Cessna 208 from Salmon-based Salmon Air crashed and caught fire at about 10 a.m.

 

The single-engine plane was flying to Hailey from Salt Lake City, Blaine County Sheriff's Chief Deputy Gene Ramsey said. It is believed to have been on approach to the Friedman Memorial Airport when it crashed in a plowed field near Baseline Road and burst into flames seven miles south of Bellevue.

 

There were no survivors and the victims haven't been identified, Ramsey said.

 

A cause for the crash near State Highway 20 hasn't been determined, he said, adding it was snowing when the plane went down in an area surrounded by mountainous terrain.

 

National Transportation Safety Board officials are expected to begin investigating the crash site today.

 

A professional pilot who flew over the wreckage shortly after impact described the plane as a turbine-powered propeller aircraft known as a Caravan and used as a cargo hauler. 

 

DEV MUKH KHALSA/Wood River Journal

 

Firefighters investigate the scene of an airplane crash Monday where it landed in a field south of Bellevue. Two were killed.

 

Ramsey said Salmon Air is a charter service that often carries air freight for United Parcel Service. Ramsey did not know what was aboard the Cessna when it crashed. Sheriff's deputies were guarding the scene Monday but heavy snow was expected to cover it, adding to the difficulty of the post-crash investigation.

 

Wednesday, December 8, 2004

 

2 killed in plane crash

 

By MATT FURBER

Express Staff Writer

 

Firefighters from Bellevue, Hailey, Wood River Fire and Rescue and Friedman Memorial Airport converged on a Bellevue Triangle farmer's field Monday morning to extinguish the blaze from a fatal crash of a Salmon Air Cessna 208 cargo plane making a delivery for UPS. Both the pilot and a passenger were killed in the crash. Photo by Willy Cook 

 

Burning air express packages told most of the story of why Bellevue Triangle residents saw unusual smoke Monday morning in the sky just south of Baseline Road.

 

A Cessna 208 Caravan cargo plane owned by Salmon Air and under contract to the United Parcel Service crashed and burned about 10:30 a.m. in a field at the south end of Kingsbury Lane, about six miles south of Bellevue, according to Allen Kenitzer, a spokesman for the Federal Aviation Administration.

 

The pilot, Fred Villaneuva, 60, of Farmington, Utah, and a passenger, Raymond Ingram, 32, of Salmon, Idaho, perished. They were identified by Blaine County Coroner Russ Mikel.

 

Only pieces of the prop and a wheel were visible from behind the fire line separating the public from the smoldering debris.

 

"It's not discernable. You can't tell what it is. It's just in pieces," said Friedman Memorial Airport Manager Rick Baird, describing the scene of the crash to a caller on his cell phone. He said the plane was on approach for a landing at the airport and the manifest for the flight showed no hazardous materials on board.

 

The FAA reported the plane, on an instrument flight plan from Sale Lake City, had been cleared to land at Friedman Memorial Airport in Hailey and apparently had begun the approach after the last radio contact at 10:20 a.m. The FAA reported the accident occurred at 10:23 a.m.

 

Weather at the time in the area included cloudy skies with a visibility of about six miles.

 

Mikel transported the bodies from the accident scene Tuesday to Boise to be autopsied, said Blaine County Deputy Sheriff Gene Ramsey.

 

National Transportation and Safety Board investigator Deborah Eckrote arrived at the scene Tuesday from Seattle to determine probable cause of the accident.

 

Fire fighting crews from Bellevue, Hailey, Wood River Fire and Rescue, Friedman Memorial Airport and other first responders extinguished the fire that was caused by the impact, Baird said.

 

Wood River Fire and Rescue Chief Bart Lassman finally cleared the scene at 4:30 p.m.

 

The single-engine turboprop crashed about 100 yards from a farmhouse and narrowly missed irrigation pivots.

 

"I was out feeding the horses. I thought it was somebody burning something," said John McClatchy, of Picabo.

 

A spokesperson for Salmon Air confirmed the loss of a plane.

 

Several customers called the Hailey UPS Store with tracking numbers to see if next day air packages had arrived, said Ryan Vossler, an employee at the Hailey store.

 

"We've had several calls from people looking for their next day air packages," Vossler said. He said the store receives nine to 10 air packages a day from the UPS hub in Salt Lake City.

 

"We expect delivery to the store between 9:30 and 10 a.m., mostly letters and documents," he said. "We haven't gotten anything today."

 

The high-wing, single-engine Caravan, still in production, first flew in the 1980s as a successor to aging aircraft such as the Beaver, Otter and other Cessna aircraft. Since the mid-1980s, some 1,200 Caravans have been manufactured, with 108 of them involved in accidents that took 238 lives. When configured for passengers, it can carry 14 persons at 200 mph speeds at altitudes of up to 27,000 feet.

 

The Idaho Mountain Express is distributed free to residents and guests throughout the Sun Valley, Idaho resort area community. Subscribers to the Idaho Mountain Express will read these stories and others in this week's issue.

 

Article Last Updated: 12/08/2004 12:15:13 AM 

 

Pilot died doing what he loved, family members say

Probe into Cessna crash continues: The Farmington man found freedom in the skies and shared that passion with his family

By Lisa Rosetta

The Salt Lake Tribune 

 

Whether on land or in the sky, Fred Villanueva was a passionate man.

 

   A decorated Vietnam War veteran and avid ham radio operator with connections around the globe, Villanueva was, above all else, a pilot who loved his job.

 

   "It was the freedom," said his son, Matthew Villanueva. "It was getting away from all attachments and being above it all."

 

   Fred Villanueva, 60, was the pilot of a Salmon Air Cessna 208 that crashed about 10:30 a.m. Monday in a field about 20 miles south of Sun Valley, Idaho. He and co-worker Raymond Ingram, 32, of Salmon, Idaho, died in the crash, said Blaine County, Idaho, Coroner Russ Mikel.

 

   The single-engine plane, bound for Sun Valley, had departed from Salt Lake City. National Transportation and Safety Board officials are still investigating the accident.

 

   Villanueva left his job with Burbank, Calif.-based cargo service Ameriflight two months ago to work for Salmon Air, a commuter air carrier based in Salmon, said his wife, Bobbie Villanueva. The couple, who were married 31 years, transferred to Farmington from Southern California in 2001, while he still worked for Ameriflight, she said.

 

   Villanueva received his private pilot license as a young man. With the help of the GI Bill, he furthered his aviation education at Gillespie Field in San Diego after   returning from a tour of duty in Vietnam in the mid-1960s.

 

   Villanueva was drafted but was a conscientious objector who refused to bear arms during the conflict. Instead, he worked as an Army medic, and was awarded the Bronze Star and the Purple Heart for pulling a soldier out of a tank even while his platoon came under heavy fire. Villanueva was struck by shrapnel during the rescue but continued assisting his comrades, said his son, Matthew.

 

   Villanueva, who was also a member of the Civil Air Patrol in Utah, instilled in his twin sons, Matthew and Mark, a passion for the sky, said Matthew Villanueva, who flies for tour company Papillon Grand 

 

   Canyon Helicopters. Mark is an air traffic controller in Oakland, Calif.

 

   "Taking family trips in the airplane as a child - that makes an impression," Matthew Villanueva said. "You just think it's the coolest thing in the world."

 

    Now every time he traverses the vast spaces of the Grand Canyon in his helicopter, he says he will be humbled by his father's life - and his death.

 

   "I don't know if I'll ever fly again without thinking about it," Matthew Villanueva said. "He died doing something he absolutely loved and that's got to be a peace of mind for anyone who enjoys what they do."

 

   On the ground, Fred Villanueva was an avid ham radio   operator for 30 years, said his wife.

 

   The son of a Filipino man and Puerto Rican woman, Villanueva loved connecting with people around the globe, she said.

 

   This month he will be featured in a ham radio club newsletter.

 

    "Hundreds of ham radio operators have phoned in" since her husband's death, Bobbie Villanueva said.

 

   Villanueva is survived by four children and two grandchildren. He will be interred at Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery in San Diego. A memorial service will be held for him in Farmington at a later date.

 

   "He just loved flying," his wife said. "It was his passion. It's what he always wanted   to do. It's what made him happy."

 

   lrosetta@sltrib.com

  

Tuesday, December 7, 2004      Twin Falls, Idaho

 

  LOCAL/STATE NEWS

 

Plane crash kills two

 

The Times-News and The Associated Press

 

BELLEVUE

 

A charter airplane crashed near Bellevue Monday, killing two people.

 

The Cessna 208 from Salmon-based Salmon Air crashed and caught fire at about 10 a.m.

 

The single-engine plane was flying to Hailey from Salt Lake City, Blaine County Sheriff's Chief Deputy Gene Ramsey said. It is believed to have been on approach to the Friedman Memorial Airport when it crashed in a plowed field near Baseline Road and burst into flames seven miles south of Bellevue.

 

There were no survivors and the victims haven't been identified, Ramsey said.

 

A cause for the crash near State Highway 20 hasn't been determined, he said, adding it was snowing when the plane went down in an area surrounded by mountainous terrain.

 

National Transportation Safety Board officials are expected to begin investigating the crash site today.

 

A professional pilot who flew over the wreckage shortly after impact described the plane as a turbine-powered propeller aircraft known as a Caravan and used as a cargo hauler. 

 

DEV MUKH KHALSA/Wood River Journal

 

Firefighters investigate the scene of an airplane crash Monday where it landed in a field south of Bellevue.

Two were killed.

 

Ramsey said Salmon Air is a charter service that often carries air freight for United Parcel Service. Ramsey did not know what was aboard the Cessna when it crashed. Sheriff's deputies were guarding the scene Monday but heavy snow was expected to cover it, adding to the difficulty of the post-crash investigation.

 

Deadly crash may be linked to ice buildup on plane wing

Farmington pilot, co-worker were killed in Idaho accident

 

By Michael N. Westley

The Salt Lake Tribune 

 

The type of airplane that crashed near Salmon, Idaho, during a light storm Monday is the subject of a review by U.S. and Canadian authorities for its vulnerability to accumulate ice on its wings.

 

   The U.S. National Transportation Safety Board and Canada's Transportation Safety Board are investigating eight separate accidents involving the Cessna Caravan since 2001 that have killed 37 people. In each case, the Caravan, also known as the Cessna 208B, lost airspeed and crashed in weather conditions known to cause icing, according to the NTSB.

 

   A "safety recommendation letter," the culmination of more than a year and a half of review, is expected to be released next week, said NTSB spokesman Paul Swan.

 

   The Cessna 208B also is the subject of at least two icing-related lawsuits filed against Cessna Aircraft Co. and operators of the aircraft. The Chicago-based Nolan Law Group says more than 50 people have died since 1990 in Cessna 208B crashes in which icing was a factor.

 

    Pilot Fred Villanueva, 60, of Farmington, and co-worker Raymond Ingram, 32, of Salmon, died Monday when their Cessna 208B, owned by Idaho-based Salmon Air, crashed about 10:30 a.m. The plane had departed Salt Lake City at 8 a.m.

 

   The plane was purchased new in 2001, said Salmon Air president JoAnn Wolters. It was the first plane the company purchased new and was its only Caravan, she said. Salmon Air is a passenger and cargo service that operates its 11-plane fleet in Utah and Idaho.

 

   "We are just a mom-and-pop operation that has grown up over 24 years. This has been a blow to the great people that work with us," Wolters said.

 

    NTSB investigators were on the scene of the Idaho crash this week to piece together the cause, which was still unknown on Thursday. A preliminary report, expected to be released soon, will not conclusively link the crash to ice buildup on the wings, said Debra Eckrote,   NTSB spokeswoman.

 

   "We're still working on gathering all the facts," she said.

 

   Icing conditions - cold temperatures and cloudy skies - were reported at the time of the crash, Eckrote said.

 

    The National Weather Service reported clouds, light snow and temperatures in the low 20s at the Salmon airport Monday morning.

 

   Though the Cessna 208B meets the minimum standards set by the Federal Aviation Administration for flying in icing conditions, the plane is vulnerable to ice buildup on the wings, said Nolan Law Group attorney Tom Ellis, whose firm represents the families of victims in four Cessna 208B crashes.

 

    Nolan Law Group to date has filed lawsuits in Alabama and Ohio, alleging the maker and operators of the plane knew about its icing problems and failed to correct them.

 

    A civil complaint filed earlier this year claims that the March 15, 2002, death of pilot Mark Stephen Blevins, who 

 

  was killed when his plane went down in Alma, Wis., was caused by a faulty wing design that gave the airplane "a dangerous propensity for degraded performance in icing and frost conditions."

 

    A lawsuit filed in July alleges that a Dec. 1, 2001, crash near Bessemer, Ala., also implies that the plane's inability to handle icing caused the deaths of Michael O'Neill and Dimitri Tohovitis.

 

   Ellis said he and his colleagues are "trying to effect a change to this aircraft in the interest of public safety." He said "it's a shame" the Cessna Aircraft Co. has not earlier addressed the problem, which he said was first discovered in the early 1990s.

 

    "Why do we have to wait for the pain of the federal government to make the change?" he asked.

 

    A spokesman for Cessna declined to comment on the lawsuits or Ellis' allegations.

 

   As ice builds up on the wings, the friction that creates lift from the air going over the top of the wing is reduced, which can cause the   plane to lose airspeed and, in extreme conditions, stall, according to a supplemental pilot safety and warning manual produced by the Cessna Corp.

 

   "The best course of action is to avoid icing conditions," the manual states.

 

   Wolters said Villanueva was properly trained to fly the 208B and was aware of the procedures necessary for flying the Caravan in icing conditions.

 

    According to the FAA, there are 584 Cessna 208Bs licensed in the United States, including six in Utah. The $1.5 million plane, which comes in four models, is used for freight or passengers and can seat up to 10 people.

 

   Other than concerns about icing, the Cessna 208B has an excellent flight record, pilots say.

 

    Ontario pilot Shawn Harmon, who has flown the Cessna 208B for about five years, said the plane's redundant fuel and electrical systems, along with a user-friendly setup and excellent navigation systems, make it reliable and easy to fly.

 

   "It's   a terrific single-engine airplane," Harmon said. He acknowledged, however, that the plane has too many unprotected areas to sustain flight in moderate to heavy icing conditions.

 

   "It can happen instantly, but you train for it," Harmon said. "We have enough experience with it to accept the limitations of the airplane."

   mwestley@sltrib.com

 

Crash cause unknown

Too early for investigators to draw conclusions

 

By MATT FURBER

Express Staff Writer

 

As investigators completed the on-site investigation Tuesday of the Dec. 13 airplane crash just south of Baseline Road in the Bellevue Triangle, the identities of two pilots were released. Circumstances that led to the crash are still unknown, however.

 

Salmon Air pilots Fred Villanueva, 60, of Farmington, Utah, and co-worker Raymond Ingram, 32, flying in a Cessna 208, both died in the crash that occurred at about 10:20 a.m. Monday in Bill Sherbine's field about 8 miles south of Friedman Memorial Airport, said Coroner Russ Mikel.

 

Villanueva, the pilot in charge of the flight, was making a delivery under contract for UPS to the Hailey airport from Salt Lake City, said Salmon Air President, JoAnn Wolters. Ingram was getting a lift home to Salmon.

 

It is too early to determine the cause of the crash, but evidence from the crash scene has been secured in Boise, said Senior NTSB Safety Investigator Debra Eckrote.

 

"It was obvious that it crashed from uncontrolled attitude," Eckrote said, adding that eyewitnesses said they saw the plane wobble before it hit the ground.

 

Eckrote said she has interviewed other pilots who were flying at the time to learn more about weather conditions and will study the remains of the aircraft in more detail. She also said she has more interviews to complete and radar data to review before she can deliver a final report of facts to the National Transportation and Safety Board. She said she must also wait for aircraft maintenance records and Villanueva's pilot record, including health records. And autopsy and toxicological reports must be completed before NTSB can determine probable cause, a decision expected to take several months.

 

"We have a little bit of every thing, but not enough to draw conclusions," Eckrote said. "I have completed interviews with the control tower. It is sounding like normal procedures were followed. There were no emergency calls from the pilot."

 

Although Villanueva and Ingram were just hired by Salmon Air within the past year, the aviation community has been hit hard by the loss of the pilots, Wolters said.

 

"Fred is well-known in the flying community. We knew Fred in Salt Lake before he started flying for us," Wolters said. "Raymond started last May. He was a very good person. He flew in Alaska before he came to us. We are close to all our people in Salt Lake and Idaho. It does more emotionally than anything else."

 

Villanueva's wife of 31 years, Bobbie, told the Salt Lake Tribune that until going to work for Salmon Air two months ago, Villanueva worked for Ameriflight, a Burbank, Calif.-based cargo service.

 

The paper also reported that Villanueva was a conscientious objector who refused to bear arms during the conflict in Vietnam. He was drafted as an Army medic and awarded the Bronze Star and the Purple Heart for pulling a soldier out of a tank under heavy fire. Despite being struck by shrapnel Villanueva continued assisting his comrades.

 

Already a private pilot, Villanueva continued his aviation training at Gillespie Field in San Diego after returning from Vietnam in the mid-1960s.

Villanueva is survived by his wife and two sons, Matthew, a Grand Canyon helicopter pilot and Mark, an Oakland, Calif., air traffic controller.

Ingram was raised in northern Utah and southern Colorado, where he graduated from Harribo High School in Colorado Springs.

 

In 1998 Ingram attended flight school at Colorado Northwestern Community College in Rangely, Colo., where he placed first in a college flying contest and flew for Island Air in Kodiak, Alaska for a year.

 

His wife Julie Beth, his son Grant and his parents Joe and Ramona Ingram of Rangely survive him. Julie Beth is pregnant with their second child.

 

"We are working with the widows and children and trying to do the best we can," Wolters said.

 

An UPS spokesman said delivery contracts with Salmon Air are continuing and the company is working with shippers to replace any goods that were destroyed in the crash.

 

 

GARY STIVERS/The Times-NEWS

 

Investigators on Tuesday sift through the rubble of a single-engine Cessna 208 aircraft that crashed south of Bellevue the previous day. The two men who were killed in the crash were identified Tuesday as Fred Villanueva of Farmington, Utah, and Raymond Ingram of Salmon.

 

"We have one witness who saw the aircraft in a nose-down attitude and wings wobbling. And then it hit the ground," Eckrole said.

 

Another witness who heard the crash and several pilots who viewed the crash site also will be interviewed as part of the investigation, Eckrole said.

 

Eckrole said her agency will issue a preliminary report within five days. But she conceded it won't show much -- just that the aircraft was cleared to land and that radar contact with it was lost.

 

Since the single-engine Cessna 208 was a commercial aircraft, there are far more records to check and verify as a part of the investigation than there would be with an accident involving a private aircraft, Eckrole said. Three to six months may pass before the National Transportation Safety Board will issue a probable cause for the accident.

 

The aircraft, owned by Salmon Air Taxi of Salmon, was carrying United Parcel Service freight when it crashed.

 

Eckrole said investigators may be able to tell more when they get what's left of the aircraft to Boise and reassemble as much of it as they can.

 

"I can kind of do a mock reconstruction just to see if there are any signatures on the aircraft that I can use to better verify the attitude and angles of attack the aircraft had when it collided with the ground," she said.

 

The wreckage, in the back of a pickup truck and filling a 20-foot trailer, will be taken to Boise for further inspection.

 

Originally published Wednesday, December 8, 2004

By Gary Stivers

Times-News correspondent

 

BELLEVUE -- Investigators released on Tuesday the names of two men who were killed when an airplane crashed just south of Bellevue a day earlier.

 

Blaine County Coroner Russ Mikel identified the pilot as 60-year-old Fred Villanueva of Farmington, Utah. Also on board was passenger Raymond Ingram, 32, of Salmon. Ingram is a pilot but was not in charge of the flight.

 

Officials with the National Transportation Safety Board began their task Tuesday of trying to determine why the Cessna Caravan cargo plane went down. Senior Air Safety Investigator Debra Eckrole said the aircraft was operating normally before contact with it was lost.

 

The aircraft departed from Salt Lake City and was preparing to land at Hailey's Friedman Memorial Airport.

 

"They reported inbound to the tower and everything sounded normal," Eckrole said. "I just listened to the tape, and everything sounded like normal communications. They eventually lost air traffic communication with the aircraft at 10:20 (a.m.)."

 

The airplane crashed moments later.

 

The windblown crash scene, a hundred yards south of Baseline Road and two miles west of Highway 75 on Bill Sherbine's ranch, is barely 25 feet in diameter. 

 

Former Kodiak pilot dies in Idaho plane crash

Article published on Thursday, December 9th, 2004

By JACOB BROOKS

Managing Editor

A former Kodiak pilot died in a plane crash in southcentral Idaho Monday morning.

 

Raymond Ingram, formerly employed by Island Air, was on board the single-engine Cessna 208 went it down during a snowstorm.

 

Authorities on Tuesday identified Ingram and one other person who died near Bellevue, Idaho.

 

“We got the call (Monday) night,” said Island Air chief pilot Mike Gerber. “We’re pretty shook up about it.”

 

Ingram, 32, worked for the Kodiak airline March 2003 to January 2004.

 

Gerber said Ingram was a “good pilot. He was cautious.”

 

According to the Idaho Statesman, the plane’s pilot was 60-year-old Fred Villanueva, of Farmington, Utah, and Ingram was a passenger. Both died in the crash.

 

However, according to the FAA report on the crash, three people, all of whom died, were listed on board the plane.

 

The single-engine Cessna 208 was owned by Salmon Air, out of Salmon, Idaho, and was carrying UPS freight when it crashed in a field and caught fire.

 

It was flying to Sun Valley from Salt Lake City, Blaine County Chief Deputy Sheriff Gene Ramsey said.

 

The National Safety Transportation Board is investigating the crash. A call placed to NSTB investigator of the crash has not been returned.

 

Ingram’s wife, Julie, worked for the Kodiak Daily Mirror as an ad builder while the couple lived here. They have one child.

 

Jacob Brooks can be reached via e-mail at jbrooks@kodiakdailymirror.com.