home | index | units | counting | geometry | algebra | trigonometry & functions | calculus
analysis | sets & logic | number theory | recreational | misc | nomenclature & history | physics

Final Answers
© 2000-2007 Gérard P. Michon, Ph.D.

Scales and Ratings:
Measuring without Units

On this site, see also:

Related Links (Outside this Site)

What is a decibel?  by  Joe Wolfe.
Richter Magnitude  by  John P. Stimac.
The Fujita Scale of Tornato Intensity
 
border
border

Scales and Ratings


(2005-08-20)   Rationalized Beaufort Wind Scale
In "force n" weather, the wind speed is proportional to   n3/2  =  nÖn

The widely-used  Beaufort scale  was devised in 1806, by Sir Francis Beaufort (1774-1857), rear admiral, hydrographer to the Royal Navy.  It was adopted by the British Admiralty in 1838, and has been in international use since 1874.  Originally, the Beaufort Wind Scale did not refer to specific wind speeds, but to the effect of the wind on a full-rigged ship, and the amount of sail which should be carried.  Since "force 12" meant a wind that 'no canvas can withstand', the original scale did not extend beyond that point.

Each Beaufort number still corresponds to a variety of common observations which can be made at sea or inland.  For example, in a "force 0" condition:  'Smoke rises vertically. Sea is like a mirror.'

Since 1946, the Beaufort scale has been defined in terms of the speed of the wind, measured by an anemometer placed 10 meters above the ground.

"Force n" means a wind speed around V.n3/2, where V is a speed of about 1.871 mph. Any speed V, in mph, between 62Ö26/169 and 146Ö46/529 yields agreement with the rounded "mph" scale below, and also with the "km/h" scale, which is somewhat less restrictive.  (Some tables give 18 mph instead of 17 mph as the upper limit for a moderate breeze; this is inconsistent with the rest of the table, for any value of V.)

(Consistent)  Beaufort Scale
Force
(n)
Denomination of the wind Wind speed  (V nÖn)
EnglishFrench(mph)(km/h)
0CalmCalme0 to 0.60 to 1
1Light airTrès légère brise0.7 to 32 to 5
2Light breezeLégère brise4 to 76 to 11
3Gentle breezePetite brise8 to 1212 to 19
4Moderate breezeJolie brise13 to 1720 to 28
5Fresh breezeBonne brise18 to 2429 to 38
6Strong breezeVent frais25 to 3139 to 49
7Near gale, moderate galeGrand frais32 to 3850 to 61
8Gale, fresh galeCoup de vent39 to 4662 to 74
9Strong galeFort coup de vent47 to 5475 to 88
10Storm, whole galeTempête55 to 6389 to 102
11(Violent) stormViolente tempête64 to 72103 to 117
12HurricaneOuraganover 73over 118

To find the Beaufort number corresponding to a given speed, one divides that speed by V, and finds the whole number closest to the cubic root of the square of that ratio.  As a result of this modern definition, the Beaufort scale can be extended beyond the traditional limit of "force 12" for extremely violent winds.

We have not traced the existence of a "standard" value of V; we shall simply note that a value V = 0.8365 m/s (or any value between 0.83626 m/s and 0.8368 m/s) will agree with the above tables in mph or km/h, but that --unexplicably-- tables published in knots imply a value of V falling in the range 0.8401 m/s to 0.8433 m/s (once the inconsistent value of 16 knots published for the upper limit of a moderate breeze is lowered to 15 knots).


(2005-08-20)   Saffir / Simpson scale for hurricanes
The customary scales for hurricanes (Beaufort force 12 and "above").

In August 1969, Hurricane "Camille" hit the Mississipi-Alabama coast with what would be "force 23" winds in an extended Beaufort scale:  200 mph to 213 mph.  However, the Beaufort scale is rarely extended  (if ever)  beyond force 12.  Instead, the strength of hurricanes is described with the following scale:

The Saffir / Simpson Hurricane Scale
Cat.Pressure at centerWind (km/h)Surge (m)Damage
1above 980 hPa120 to 1531.2m to 1.5mMinimal
2965 hPa to 980 hPa154 to 1771.8m to 2.4mModerate
3945 hPa to 965 hPa178 to 2092.7m to 3.7mExtensive
4920 hPa to 945 hPa210 to 2494.0m to 5.5mExtreme
5below 920 hPa250 +5.5m +Catastrophic

In the Atlantic, the record-breaking hurricane season of 2005 included three category-5 hurricanes, named Katrina, Rita and Wilma (in chronological order).  At this writing (Oct. 2005) Wilma is the most intense hurricane ever observed in the Atlantic basin, featuring the lowest sea-level atmospheric pressure ever recorded in the Western Hemisphere outside of tornadoes  (882 hPa).  In the Northwest Pacific Ocean, only 9  typhoons  have surpassed the intensity of Wilma.  (The terms  typhoon  and  hurricane  describe the same phenomenon, but are used in different parts of the Globe.)

The costliest hurricane ever was  hurricane Katrina  (August 23 to 31, 2005) which caused an estimated $200 billion in damages and at least 1281 fatalities  (official count at this writing).  After hitting land as a mere category-1 hurricane north of Miami on August 25, the eye of Katrina made landfall again in Lousiana at 6:10am (CDT) on Monday, August 29, 2005.  as a category-4 hurricane...  By 11 am, the storm surge had breached the levee system protecting  New Orleans  from Lake Pontchartrain.  Most of the city was subsequently flooded.

Hurricane Names

Normally, the names of Hurricanes comes from a preapproved yearly list of 21 names with initals A through W (skipping Q and U) which is reused every 6 years, except that names of major hurricanes are retired and replaced...  The 2005 season had so many major storms that the last ones had to be named after letters from the Greek alphabet  (Alpha, Beta, Gamma, Delta, Epsilon, Zeta).

Atlantic Hurricane Names
200420052006200720082009 20102011
Alex
Bonnie
Charley
Danielle
Earl
Frances
Gaston
Hermine
Ivan
Jeanne
Karl
Lisa
Matthew
Nicole
Otto
Paula
Richard
Shary
Tomas
Virginie
Walter
Arlene
Bret
Cindy
Dennis
Emily
Franklin
Gert
Harvey
Irene
Jose
Katrina
Lee
Maria
Nate
Ophelia
Philippe
Rita
Stan
Tammy
Vince
Wilma
 
Alpha
Beta
Gamma
Delta
Epsilon
Zeta
Alberto
Beryl
Chris
Debby
Ernesto
Florence
Gordon
Helene
Isaac
Joyce
Kirk
Leslie
Michael
Nadine
Oscar
Patty
Rafael
Sandy
Tony
Valerie
William
Andrea
Barry
Chantal
Dean
Erin
Felix
Gabrielle
Humberto
Ingrid
Jerry
Karen
Lorenzo
Melissa
Noel
Olga
Pablo
Rebekah
Sebastien
Tanya
Van
Wendy
Arthur
Bertha
Cristobal
Dolly
Edouard
Fay
Gustav
Hanna
Ike
Josephine
Kyle
Laura
Marco
Nana
Omar
Paloma
René
Sally
Teddy
Vicky
Wilfred
Ana
Bill
Claudette
Danny
Erika
Fred
Grace
Henri
Ida
Joaquin
Kate
Larry
Mindy
Nicholas
Odette
Peter
Rose
Sam
Teresa
Victor
Wanda
Alex
Bonnie
Colin
Danielle
Earl
Fiona
Gaston
Hermine
Igor
Julia
Karl
Lisa
Matthew
Nicole
Otto
Paula
Richard
Shary
Tomas
Virginie
Walter
Arlene
Bret
Cindy
Don
Emily
Franklin
Gert
Harvey
Irene
Jose
Katia
Lee
Maria
Nate
Ophelia
Philippe
Rina
Sean
Tammy
Vince
Whitney

The following names have been retired, as of 2005:   Agnes (1972), Alicia (1983), Allen (1980), Allison (2001), Andrew (1992), Anita (1977), Audrey (1957), Betsy (1965), Beulah (1967), Bob (1991), Camille (1969), Carla (1961), Carmen (1974), Carol (1954), Celia (1970), Cesar (1996), Charley (2004), Cleo (1964), Connie (1955), David (1979), Dennis (2005), Diana (1990), Diane (1955), Donna (1960), Dora (1964), Edna (1968), Elena (1985), Eloise (1975), Fabian (2003), Fifi (1974), Flora (1963), Floyd (1999), Fran (1996), Frances (2004), Frederic (1979), Georges (1998), Gilbert (1988), Gloria (1985), Hattie (1961), Hazel (1954), Hilda (1964), Hortense (1996), Hugo (1989), Inez (1966), Ione (1955), Iris (2001), Isabel (2003), Isidore (2002), Ivan (2004), Janet (1955), Jeanne (2004), Joan (1988), Juan (2003), Katrina (2005), Keith (2000), Klaus (1990), Lenny (1999), Lili (2002), Luis (1995), Marilyn (1995), Michelle (2001), Mitch (1998), Opal (1995), Rita (2005), Roxanne (1995), Stan (2005) and Wilma (2005).


(2005-08-20)   Fujita scale for tornadoes
Local twisters are primarily measured against a 6-rung scale  (F0 to F5).

Within tornadoes, the wind can reach speeds in excess of 280 mph  (450 km/h).  If the Beaufort scale was applicable, this would mean force 28 or 29.  Instead, all tornadoes are ranked using the following scale, from weakest to strongest:

The Fujita Tornado Scale
FnEffectsWind speed  (km/h)
F0Twisted antennas, broken branches60 to 110
F1Uprooted trees, vehicles turned over120 to 170
F2Lifted rooves, small projectiles180 to 250
F3Walls tipped over, large projectiles260 to 330
F4Houses destroyed, some trees lifted340 to 410
F5Large structures lifted, incredible damages420 to 510


(2006-12-02)   Measuring in Decibels  (dB)
A general-purpose logarithmic scale for physical  power.

In a given medium, a signal carries a certain power  (or a power flux)  proportional to the square of an associated "amplitude".  (Various physical choices are possible for amplitudes.)

The  relative magnitude  of two such signals may be expressed equivalently as a logarithmic function of the ratios of their powers (P) or as the same logarithmic function of the squares of their amplitudes (A).  If decibels (dB) are used, the  relative  magnitude of the signal (compared to some other signal of rererence) is defined by either of the following expressions, which involve  decimal  logarithms.

Magnitude in dB   =   10  log( P/P0 )   =   20  log( A/A0 )

When the amplitude doubles, the power becomes 4 times as high and the magnitude is raised by roughly 6 dB.  If the amplitude is multiplied by 10, the power is 100 times higher and the magnitude is raised exactly 20 dB.

From relative ratios to absolute measurements :

Decibels are most useful to express ratios of related signals (for example the signals at the input and the output of an electronic amplifier).  However, specifying a conventional "reference" signal readily establishes an "absolute" decibel scale.  Each choice of a particular reference establishes a different "absolute" scale. 

The most popular general-purpose measurement based on decibels is the "dBm" for which the zero level (0 dB) is a signal whose total (harmonic) power is one milliwatt  (1 mW).  A power of  0.1 mW,  is  -10 dBm  a power of  10mW  is  10dBm,  a power of  100mW  is  20 dBm,  a power of  1 W is  30 dBm,  etc.


(2006-12-11)   Apparent and Absolute Magnitude of Stars
The absolute magnitude of a star is its apparent magnitude 10 pc away.

Ptolemy rated all stars wisible with the naked-eye, from brightest (first magnitude) to faintest (sixth magnitude).  It turns out that a star of the first magnitude in this ancient system is about 100 times as bright as a star of the sixth magnitude.  Thus, in 1854, the British astronomer N.R. Pogson proposed to turn that ptolemaic rating system into a strict logarithmtic scale, where a difference of 5 magnitudes would separate two stars whose brighnesses are in a ratio of 100 to 1.

So specified, the modern system of  stellar magnitudes  extends to faint objects (beyond magnitude 6) as well as very bright ones (the brightest stars, the planets, the Moon, the Sun) which are assigned a magnitude less than 1, or even a negative magnitude...  The Sun has a magnitude of  -26.7.  With a magnitude of -1.6, Sirius is the brightest object outside the solar system.  The faintest stars detected so far by the largest telescopes have a magnitude of 23 or so...

As brightness decreases by a factor of  100 1/5, magnitude increases by one unit.  This factor is known as  Pogson's ratio, in honor of N.R. Pogson (1829-1891).

100 0.2   = 10 0.4   =   2.51188643150958...

This simply means that one star magnitude is exactly equal to  4 decibels (4 dB).  However, star magnitudes are very rarely (if ever) expressed in decibels.  Historically, the relation is reversed:  The idea for expressing powers in decibels came from the stellar magnitude system !

There are 20 stars of the first magnitude (magnitude less than 1.5) 60 stars of the second magnitude (magnitude between 1.5 and 2.5) about 180 stars of the third magnitude (between 2.5 and 3.5) etc.  This tripling pattern holds for relatively bright stars but tends to be less explosive thereafter (it looks more like a mere doubling for stars around magnitude 20).

Most physicists would probably prefer to base star magnitudes on their bolometric output powers  (in which all electromagnetic frequencies carry equal weight).  This is rarely done, if ever, except for the Sun itself.

Ideally, the visual magnitude of a star should be based on the power it emits in the visible spectrum, using the same standard photopic response of the human retina on which the definition of the lumen is based  (although the dark-adapted scotopic response might be more relevant to direct telescopic observations by humans).

In actual practice, however, various standard filters are used instead which allow an automated determination of a star's magnitude in various portions of the electromagnetic spectrum.  As the emission spectrum of a star is, in the main, very similar to that of a  blackbody, precise comparisons of such different flavor of magnitudes allow the determination of a star's surface temperature (T).

Regardless of what spectrum-specific "flavor" of star magnitude is used, the  absolute  magnitude of a star is defined as what its apparent magnitude would be if it was observed at a distance of 10 pc  (10 parsecs is about  32.6 light-years).  To determine the absolute magnitude of a star, its distance must first be estimated  (using parallax or other methods)  so that the apparent magnitude can be adjusted, knowing that the observed power flux varies as the inverse square of the distance.

Conversely, the absolute magnitude of some stars may be known from other considerations (e.g., the absolute magnitude of a so-called Cepheid variable star is a function of the period of its oscillation in brightness).  This allows some distances to be estimated from apparent magnitudes, without the need for parallax measurements  (which are certainly not practical for intergalactical distances).


(2005-11-26)   The Richter Scale of Earthquake Magnitudes
The seismic energy radiated is the basis of a rationalized Richter scale.

The original Richter Scale was devised in 1935 at the California Institute of Technology by Beno Gutenberg and Dr. Charles F. Richter.  More modern versions of that scale have been devised which are adequate to measure the largest earthquakes while being roughly compatible with the traditonal 1935 definition for small earthquakes.

The  1935 Richter Scale  of Richter and Gutenberg  (now called local magnitude) was defined as a practical  logarithmic  scale;  strictly based on readings from a particular type of instrument then used at CalTech:  The Wood-Anderson torsion seismometer.  Magnitude 0  was arbitrarily assigned to an earthquake that would cause a maximum combined horizontal displacement of 1 micron  (1 micrometer)  on such an instrument at  100 km from the epicenter.  (This reference level is so low that negative magnitude are very rarely used.)  If this amplitude increases by a factor of 10, the local magnitude increases by one unit.

The problem with this viewpoint is that the amplitude originally considered by Richter is not a simple function of the energy released, except for the smallest earthquakes.  There are nonlinearities and the duration of the earthquake is also an important factor, especially for very large quakes which may last several minutes...

 Come back later, we're
 still working on this one...

Mercalli Intensity Scale: The effects measured at a particular location. Wood-Anderson seismographs at Caltech. Charles F. Richter & Beno Gutenberg: log E = 11.8 + 1.5 R Seismic Moment, Hiro Kanamori: M is about 20000 E.

 Come back later, we're
 still working on this one...

Richter Magnitude

border
border
visits since August 20, 2005
 (c) Copyright 2000-2007, Gerard P. Michon, Ph.D.