About "crefwatch"

It's your money!


My name is Timothy Buchman. I'm 56 years old, with an A.B. from Bowdoin College (1972, Math) and an M.F.A. from Smith College (1974, Theater and Speech). From 1974 to 1979, I was Assistant Professor of Dramatic Arts at Amherst College.

As soon as I was eligible, I signed up at Amherst for TIAA-CREF. Partly because I started early, it's the best investment I've ever made. I had a few jobs that used Mutual Of America, but later moved those funds to a GSRA at TIAA-CREF. I've recruited dozens of friends and family to become TIAA-CREF participants, and agitated successfully for companies where I worked to offer TIAA-CREF as a 403(b) plan. I helped my mother chose TIAA-CREF over AARP for her Long-Term Care Insurance. (Ka-pow: Then they sold the business to Met Life!) She's already retired with a TIAA-CREF annuity.

I'm currently a union stagehand in New York City. My theater, where I run the light board, is operated by a not-for-profit tax-exempt foundation that offers us TIAA-CREF. Before that, I was a house stagehand at Avery Fisher Hall, where Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts offered TIAA-CREF (and other) 403(b)'s.

It breaks my heart to set myself up in opposition to them. But it's not the same company I originally joined. You can't believe everything you read on the internet, so I don't expect you to take my opinions as fact, or my facts as correct (although I've tried to check everything I've posted here.) But I hope you'll pay close attention, to make sure that your money is well-handled.

This site is intended to focus on expenses, the ones we pay to TIAA-CREF to invest our money. I don't mean to suggest that any money-management company, even a non-profit, can do business for free. But the company that was originally set up by the Carnegie Foundation to work for a public good may have strayed from that mission. You be the judge.

Conflicts of Interest: TIAA-CREF is my single largest retirement investment. I have no desire to weaken the company, quite the contrary! My only direct investment in financial services companies are regional bank stocks which do not compete with TIAA-CREF. My non TIAA-CREF mutual funds certainly own the stocks of competitors, but I have nothing to do with their investment selections.

By the way, at least for now, TIAA-CREF is not publicly owned. TIAA says they're not-for-profit in their New York State insurance company charter, and CREF is a New York State Type B not-for-profit corporation.

This site is blue and white in memory of the annual statements/benefit estimates TIAA-CREF used to send out, which were called "Blue and White Sheets".
Copyright © 2008 Timothy H. Buchman
Trademark notices     Privacy statement
Back to Home
 
Published: January 10, 2004
Modified: June 23, 2008